Eunomia's assessment of Afvalfonds' collection plan for deposit return cans in public spaces - summary

Eunomia estimates that the Afvalfonds proposal is not consumer-friendly enough to expect that the statutory 90% separate collection target can be achieved. Afvalfonds makes too many choices that compromise consumer-friendliness, posing risks that, according to Eunomia, will likely “have a cumulative effect resulting in too many cans being ‘lost’ to meet the 90% target”;

Suze Govers

This page is automatically translated. A human review will follow soon.

In its assessment, Eunomia draws upon an international benchmark and interviews with Dutch experts and practitioners from both industry (with knowledge of deposit return systems and the drinks market) and local authorities (with knowledge of waste management, planning, and municipal services).

Eunomia's findings in brief:

Eunomia estimates that the Afvalfonds proposal is insufficiently consumer-friendly to expect that the statutory 90% separate collection target can be achieved. Afvalfonds makes too many choices that compromise consumer-friendliness, thereby presenting risks that, according to Eunomia, are likely to "have a cumulative effect resulting in too many cans being 'lost' to achieve the 90% target";

Regarding the statutory deadline of 31 December 2022, Eunomia concludes that they consider it highly problematic to arrange everything for this parallel and complex system within the statutory timeframe. The lack of detailed planning in the Afvalfonds proposal and the absence of transparency concerning the current state of affairs made answering this question somewhat more difficult, but Eunomia nonetheless feels confident enough to state this.

Eunomia: Deposit Return in the Netherlands

An assessment of the Afvalfonds proposal for beverage can collection in the public domain

Eunomia: Deposit Return in the Netherlands

An assessment of the Afvalfonds proposal for beverage can collection in the public domain

The full report

Background to the Eunomia study

Former State Secretary Stientje van Veldhoven decided on 3 February 2021 that, from 31 December 2022, beverage cans would carry a deposit and a collection system must be operational that collects 90% of cans separately. Because supermarkets refuse to collect cans in their stores, the Afvalfonds (representing the packaging industry) published an alternative plan on 14 December 2021: they want to collect deposit cans outside of supermarkets via reverse vending machines in the public domain.

Various stakeholders, including the environmental movement, Members of Parliament, the Consumentenbond, and Metaal Verpakkingen Nederland, voiced critical reactions and questions regarding the Afvalfonds plan to collect cans in the public domain. In the meantime, the VNG and NVRD have also expressed their concerns more emphatically. Partly for this reason, the environmental organisation Recycling Netwerk commissioned an evaluation of the Afvalfonds plan from international research consultancy Eunomia, renowned for its work on the circular economy and research for the European Commission. In this press release, we provide a summary of the main findings.

Key points of the Afvalfonds plan

In December 2021, the Afvalfonds published its plan for collecting cans via reverse vending machines in outdoor spaces. The main points of this plan are as follows:

Following full roll-out, there will be 3,300 return locations where people can return cans and get their deposit back. All return locations will have at least one reverse vending machine;

Approximately 3,000 of the return locations are planned not inside, but "near" supermarkets, with the remaining 300 locations planned in so-called high-traffic locations such as public transport stations and petrol stations;

For residential-retail areas with one supermarket, the Afvalfonds envisages a return location in a nearby public space, and in the case of areas with multiple supermarkets (2–8), the target is a collection point within a 500-metre radius of the most central supermarket;

Outdoor reverse vending machines will be covered and sheltered, placed in so-called 'shelters';

It is a phased model. By 31 December 2022, an 80% roll-out is envisaged: 1,300 reverse vending machines outside stores and at high-traffic locations, and 1,500 additional locations guaranteed by supermarkets. The aim is to provide the 3,300 return locations by April 2024, some of which will still be temporary. During 2023 and 2024, the temporary locations guaranteed by supermarkets will be replaced by locations "near" supermarkets;

In addition to the return locations where consumers receive their deposit back, an estimated 5,000 voluntary return locations are expected to be set up by 2023, where consumers can dispose of their cans in designated collection bins and the bin owner can claim the deposit. In the long term, 10,000 of these voluntary points are expected;

The Afvalfonds presents the outdoor return points as a first step towards 'circular hubs' where other material streams can also be collected in the future (scaling up).

Eunomia methodology

Eunomia Research and Consulting has extensive experience with deposit return systems in countries around the world and has worked with governments, manufacturers, retailers, system operators, and NGOs. For this report, in addition to its own wealth of knowledge, Eunomia conducted targeted interviews with Dutch experts and practitioners, encompassing both "industry" perspectives (a category of interviewees with expertise and insight into deposit system provision and the Dutch drinks market) and "municipal" perspectives (a category of interviewees with expertise and insight into waste management, planning, and municipal services).

The vast majority of interviewees chose to remain anonymous. These requests are respected throughout the report, which in some cases limits Eunomia's ability to provide specific information and sources relating to the Dutch context. The input from Dutch interviewees was used by Eunomia to test its own international knowledge and experience against the Dutch context and to highlight unique challenges or opportunities in the Netherlands.

Main findings of Eunomia

Risks to achieving 90% separate collection

Eunomia first examined how likely it is that the Afvalfonds framework for collection outside supermarkets will achieve the statutory target of 90% separate collection for cans by 2024. "Reaching the 90% separate collection target means matching the best deposit return systems in the world", according to Eunomia. A collection target of 90% means that only 1 in 10 cans may fall outside the system. "High-performing deposit return systems place people at the centre, because public participation determines whether a deposit return system succeeds or fails".

For this primary question, Eunomia therefore benchmarked the Afvalfonds plan against the characteristics of deposit return systems with a return rate of 90% or more.

These characteristics are:

the level of the deposit amount, which provides the economic incentive to participate;

a highly accessible network of return points, the absolute number of return points and their placement relative to daily routines; a consistent and uncomplicated system design, which facilitates understanding and motivation to participate;

clear communication directed at the consumer, to support all of the above.

No single factor on its own determines how well the deposit return system functions. It is the combination of and interaction between these factors that determines how convincingly user-friendly the system is, and whether the 90% separate collection rate can be achieved.

The minimum deposit amount is set by law at €0.15, and this applies to cans. Because the deposit amount, when set against the international context, is neither low nor high, the other factors are decisive.

Here, Eunomia identifies several substantial risks to achieving the collection target.

First and foremost, the number of collection points in the Afvalfonds plan is far below the number of collection points in deposit return systems that achieve 90% return rates, see Table 5-1. The Afvalfonds plan provides for 2.5 reverse vending machines and 1.9 collection points per 10,000 inhabitants. By comparison, Germany has 5.3 reverse vending machines and 16 return points per 10,000 inhabitants. This means that the Afvalfonds plan gives people significantly less opportunity to return their cans in exchange for the deposit they paid upon purchase.

Furthermore, Eunomia refers to an earlier study by EY Parthenon (2019) on system design for small plastic bottles commissioned by the Dutch government, in which EY concluded that with around 12,000 return locations at retail points, a collection rate of 92–93% would be achieved. This confirms Eunomia's analysis that the low number of collection points in the Afvalfonds plan poses a risk to achieving the 90% collection target, not only in comparison with practice abroad, but also within the previously studied Dutch context.

The voluntary return points, which form a major component of the Afvalfonds plan, do not qualify as part of the deposit return system according to Eunomia, simply because people do not receive a deposit refund there and these points therefore do not provide the economic incentive to return your can. Even when they are included, the density of the collection network is still "much lower" than in deposit return systems with a return rate of 90% or more.

Apart from the numbers, the location of the collection points also creates a barrier to consumer participation. 'Return-to-retail', i.e. collection at retail points such as supermarkets, performs quantitatively better internationally in terms of collection compared to systems where people have to travel to a different location, due to its consumer-friendliness. Furthermore, nowhere in the world is there a deposit return system that achieves a 90% return rate without return-to-retail (see Figure 3-3). In other words: only deposit return systems with collection at retail points achieve return rates of 90% as prescribed by law in the Netherlands.

Eunomia concludes that the Afvalfonds plan to place reverse vending machines "near the supermarket" cannot be compared to return in supermarkets in terms of consumer-friendliness. For example, the reverse vending machines in the public domain are unmanned, which means there is no one on hand to resolve the problem quickly in the event of error messages, something that supermarket staff can normally handle promptly. Eunomia also points out that, under the Afvalfonds plan, consumers will have to go out of their way for cans rather than returning them where they already go: the supermarket. Expert interviews conducted by Eunomia also reveal doubts as to whether it is feasible in practice to guarantee across the whole of the Netherlands the 'maximum 500 metres to the central supermarket' target communicated by the Afvalfonds, which will further increase inconvenience for the consumer.

In addition, Eunomia considers the habits and preferences of Dutch consumers. In this regard, Eunomia highlights that Dutch consumers have already developed the habit of returning their deposit-bearing beverage containers to the supermarket. According to a survey by the Consumentenbond, 89% of Dutch consumers also express a (strong) preference for returning both cans and bottles to retail points. Deviating from these habits and preferences places consumer-friendliness, and thus participation, under strain.

Finally, Eunomia emphasises that there is no other deposit return system where consumers must go to different locations for different containers. Even in the case of a phased introduction, as in the Netherlands, consumers can normally return all deposit-bearing beverage packaging to the same collection points in exchange for their deposit. The fact that, according to Afvalfonds, consumers must visit different locations for different beverage containers makes the system less user-friendly and also runs counter to established routines.

Clear, informative, and motivating communication about the system is hindered by the introduced complexity. Here, Eunomia notes, for instance, the fact that consumers must be directed to a different location for cans than for plastic bottles and glass beer bottles. The consultancy also points out that this plan does not create a nationally coherent system for cans, as the implementation will be "hyper-local" due to the need to identify suitable locations at municipal level. This poses serious barriers to establishing a national communication campaign. Moreover, the fact that the Afvalfonds plan envisages a phased roll-out means that communication will have to be adjusted over time and must encourage new consumer behaviours at various junctures.

Receive updates and calls to action. 1 to 2 times a month.

Let's stay connected

Receive updates and calls to action. 1 to 2 times a month.

Let's stay connected

Contact

2e Daalsedijk 6a
3551 EJ Utrecht, The Netherlands
info@fairresourcefoundation.org

International networks
Registered Charity
CBF Approved Charity Logo
Logo ANBI - Public Benefit Organisation

RSIN (ANBI): 812123621
Chamber of Commerce (KvK): 08111421
VAT: NL81 2123 621 B01

Our socials
No (Plastic) Filter
Deposit Alliance
Interpool
©2026Fair Resource Foundation

Website by Digitalnatives

Contact

2e Daalsedijk 6a
3551 EJ Utrecht, The Netherlands
info@fairresourcefoundation.org

International networks
Registered Charity
CBF Approved Charity Logo
Logo ANBI - Public Benefit Organisation

RSIN (ANBI): 812123621
Chamber of Commerce (KvK): 08111421
VAT: NL81 2123 621 B01

Our socials
No (Plastic) Filter
Deposit Alliance
Interpool
©2026Fair Resource Foundation

Website by Digitalnatives