Customers are footing the bill for McDonald's pollution
For two years now, all catering establishments in the Netherlands have been required to serve food and drinks in reusable packaging for on-site consumption. Yet, since summer 2024, McDonald’s Netherlands has been breaking the law by offering single-use plastic-coated paper cups in its restaurants. This makes the country's largest fast-food chain not only non-compliant, wasting raw materials, but it even makes consumers pay extra for it by levying a surcharge on this disposable cup.

All cafés, restaurants and hotels serving food and drink for on-site consumption must offer it in reusable packaging[1]. This law has applied in the Netherlands since January 2024, as the implementation of European regulations. The aim is to reduce the use of disposable packaging containing plastic. Since August 2024, McDonald’s has already been violating[2] this law by reintroducing disposable paper cups with a plastic coating for on-site consumption (for drinks and their McFlurry) alongside offering reusable packaging. In addition, the restaurants charge their customers €0.15 per disposable cup, whereas this “SUP surcharge” should only be charged for takeaway packaging. The largest fast-food chain in the Netherlands therefore fails to comply with the rules and, what is more, earns extra money from its customers by creating a revenue model around the banned disposable packaging.
Market leader McDonald’s is allowed to ignore the rules and even make a profit from it? Its competitors, both large chains and small businesses that do play by the rules and thereby contribute to a circular packaging system, are faced with an uneven playing field. Fair Resource Foundation submitted an enforcement request to the inspectorate on 26 November.
McDonald’s bypasses reuse…
In its Dutch Impact Report 2024–2025 (p. 15), published in October 2025, the chain writes that it believes “not in exclusively reusable packaging, but in a mix of solutions”.
This sounds nuanced, but behind the scenes, McDonald’s is actively lobbying against reusable packaging. In the European Union, the company is doing this through the much-criticised No Silver Bullet campaign, and in the Netherlands through talks with, among others, former State Secretary Chris Jansen, Special Government Envoy for the Circular Economy Steven van Eijck and various MPs. The company also influences public opinion by portraying reuse as “bad for the environment“ via interviews and sponsored articles in (inter)national media (2023, 2024, 2025). But perhaps even more importantly: McDonald’s Netherlands is setting its own reuse system up to fail.
The impact report states that their reusable cups are only reused 3.3 times in Dutch restaurants. A figure that is much lower than that of well-designed, effective reuse systems. Their French counterparts show that things can be done better, with an average of 33.9 reuses for on-site consumption.
McDonald’s Netherlands Impact Report 2024-2025 (p. 15)
It is hardly surprising that reuse is not working in the Dutch restaurants:
Unclear ordering process: For dine-in, you can choose a disposable cup alongside a reusable cup, which then states “takeaway” (photo 4);
The top (first) options on the order kiosk menu are disposable cups;
There is no deposit on reusable cups for dine-in, meaning customers who want to finish their drinks later take the cup outside and do not return it, or accidentally throw it in the bin. There is therefore no incentive to return reusable packaging for on-site consumption (photo 1, see also research by the Zwerfinator);
For some of the reusable dine-in cups, no information is displayed in the ordering process: it is therefore not clear what kind of cup your order will come in (and what you should do with it). For example: Coca Cola Regular says ‘reusable cup’ and Coca Cola Zero shows no information (even though it is also served in a reusable cup). Note: Does not apply to all restaurants checked (photo 5);
Reusable and disposable cups look very similar (photo 1), while the return process is different; Disposable cup: in the bin;
Reusable for dine-in: back to the collection station;
Reusable for takeaway: returned (where is unclear) to get the deposit back;
Branded cups that can be seen as collector's items (photo 1);
Identical disposable paper lid on all cups (disposable and reusable) (photo 2);
No communication in the restaurants about the benefits of reuse: little to no action is taken to encourage customers to choose the reusable option;
For McFlurry, when we ordered both disposable and reusable packaging, we were served only disposable packaging (photo 3).
Specifically regarding reusable takeaway packaging: there is lack of clarity about how and where consumers can return their packaging, for instance whether they will get a deposit back; and whether they have to queue up again among other customers to do so (photo 6).
![]() Photo 1 – Medium cups. From left to right: single-use in the restaurant, reusable in the restaurant, reusable for takeaway. | ![]() Photo 2 – Single-use cardboard lid on single-use (top) and reusable (bottom) packaging for on-site consumption. |
|---|---|
![]() Photo 3 – Order of two McFlurrys, one in disposable packaging and one in reusable packaging. Both served in disposable packaging | ![]() Photo 4 – Dine-in ordering process: each drink was shown twice, in disposable packaging (1st option) or reusable packaging (2nd option) |
![]() Photo 5 – Dine-in ordering process for some restaurants: no mention whatsoever on reusable packaging | ![]() Photo 6 – Communication on reusable packaging for takeaway |
![]() Photo 7 – Return station for reusable cups with space to empty liquids |
These are all features that do not align with the Reuse Step-by-Step Plan developed by Mission Reuse on behalf of the Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management. Although certain parts of the system have been well thought through by McDonald’s (at the checkout there is a quick deposit refund and there are reasonably clear return stations), this is insufficient to achieve the desired return rates. Even so, McDonald’s actively communicates that reuse does not work. But a flawed system cannot be used to assess the environmental and economic performance of reuse.
False assumptions and unfounded claims: the truth about disposable paper packaging
Meanwhile, McDonald’s continues to mislead consumers about how “green” their paper packaging supposedly is compared to reusable alternatives. However, replacing single-use or reusable plastic with disposable paper (with a plastic coating) ignores the enormous problems created by the growing demand for paper. Every year, 3 billion trees are cut down, forests in Estonia and Finland have become net CO₂ emitters, and forest fires and biodiversity loss are on the rise (Environmental Paper Network).
And that is not to mention transport, energy and water consumption: studies show that the endless cycle of extracting raw materials, producing, using and processing disposable packaging has a greater environmental impact than reuse in well-designed systems (Rethink Plastic Alliance, 2021; Eunomia, 2023).
Breaking the rules and crushing the reuse industry
For the past eighteen months, McDonald’s Netherlands has been selling drinks for on-site consumption in disposable packaging containing plastic, in violation of the law. The fast-food giant—larger than KFC and Burger King combined (the latter shows that reuse does work through consumer-friendly systems)—therefore fails to comply with the Dutch single-use plastics regulations. For this reason, Fair Resource Foundation has submitted an enforcement request to the Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate (ILT).
In addition, by deliberately designing a flawed reuse system and then blaming reuse as a concept, the chain is threatening the rise of the Dutch circular industry. McDonald’s is taking the wind out of the sails of progressive, innovative Dutch reuse entrepreneurs who are working towards a cleaner world with lower costs for society.
Reuse is the future, and the future is now
There is good reason why the Dutch government set reuse as the standard: it wants 40% fewer disposable cups and food containers containing plastic by 2026 and an end to litter. This can only be achieved by completely phasing out packaging containing plastic or through the introduction of reuse systems. McDonald’s itself advocates “an approach based on real-world data regarding the actual environmental impact of reusable packaging“ (Impact Report 2024–2025, p. 15).
The results are clear: optimised reuse systems outperform disposable packaging, both in environmental impact and cost efficiency. Mandatory reuse is therefore an effective, data-driven solution to the throwaway society we have collectively created. Burger King, McDonald’s largest competitor, shows, however, that reuse does work through consumer-friendly systems, even in the fast-food sector. In other sectors, many good examples can also be found at home and abroad. Think of theme parks (Disneyland Paris, Walibi, Diergaarde Blijdorp, Toverland), sports clubs (v.v. Oudehaske, v.v. Oegstgeest) and city-wide events (Leids Ontzet, Gentse Feesten).
McDonald’s and government: your move for genuine circularity
McDonald’s Netherlands has made it clear that it is “not happy” with the new rules for reusable packaging, and prefers paper packaging with a plastic coating. By influencing legislation, steering public opinion and allowing its own reuse system in the Netherlands to fail, McDonald’s is trying to get its own way. In its quest to maintain the status quo of disposable packaging, the company does not even shy away from breaking the law and making extra money off its customers.
We call on Thierry Aartsen, State Secretary for Infrastructure and Water Management, to ensure clear and unambiguous legislation for all sectors, as well as enforcement. That is the only way to genuinely achieve the transition from single-use to reuse. As the minister himself already pointed out during the last Circular Economy Committee Debate: “it would be a shame” to go back to “paper cups”. Right now, it is essential not to roll back existing reuse legislation, but to strengthen it (see our previous suggestions on this).
Businesses that “have invested and want to move forward”, as Aartsen called them, need clear, consistent rules to be able to build well-functioning reuse systems. In addition, enforcement is indispensable, and it can make a big difference when the most influential fast-food company, which is breaking the law, is held accountable.
Finally, we call on McDonald’s to take responsibility and respect the law, stop their foot-dragging, and no longer make customers pay for banned disposable packaging. As market leader, McDonald’s sets the direction of the market. The company is keen to “use its scale to make a positive impact”. We can only applaud that, on the road to reusable packaging.
Footnotes
[1] Unless high-quality recycled rPET is used and recycled again (think of soft cups at festivals).
[2] We visited the following 12 restaurants to investigate the reuse system: Arnhem Station, Beestenmarkt (Leiden), Coolsingel (Rotterdam), Donkersteeg (Leiden), Hazeldonk-Oost (Hazeldonk), Hoogstraat (Rotterdam), Lange Vie (Utrecht), Oudegracht (Utrecht), Persant Snoepweg (Leiderdorp), Rhijnhofweg (Oegstgeest), Rooseveltstraat (Leiden), Turfmarkt 95 (The Hague)












