PwC report for Stichting OPEN advocates monopoly within EPR, but ignores criticism
Stichting OPEN is the only Dutch producer responsibility organisation for e-waste. They commissioned a study by PwC, which allegedly shows that a market with a single PRO is the most effective and efficient for the implementation of EPR. While this outcome is favourable for Stichting OPEN, is this conclusion actually correct?

This page is automatically translated. A human review will follow soon.
The story behind the results of Stichting OPEN
First, some background information on the results of Stichting OPEN. Since 2019, the European Union has required in Directive 2012/19 that 65% of the three-year average of electrical and electronic equipment (EEE) placed on the market be separately collected by producers, complemented by minimum targets per product category for preparation for reuse and recycling. Although producers are individually obligated by law to achieve these targets, this is often very difficult in practice. For this reason, producers and importers unite in so-called producer responsibility organisations (PROs) that collectively implement extended producer responsibility. At the start of this target, the collection rate of waste EEE in the Netherlands stood at 48% and the market consisted of multiple PROs, including Wecycle and WEEE Nederland. Wecycle believed that a monopoly position would lead to achieving the targets more quickly. They therefore decided to apply for a generally binding declaration (AVV), with the promise to achieve the statutory 65% target within two years. The Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management subsequently approved the AVV, compelling the producers, municipalities, and retailers affiliated with WEEE Nederland to join Wecycle, which from that point onwards continued as Stichting OPEN. WEEE Nederland later became an executing body of Stichting OPEN.
However, the promise to reach 65% within two years was not fulfilled, and now, five years later, the target remains out of reach: in 2024, only 32% was collected. Stichting OPEN has, incidentally, criticised the 65% target—and understandably so, given that this target focuses solely on recycling and thus does not take reuse, repair, or other circular strategies into account. The sharp rise in solar panels also distorts the picture, as they now account for a third of the total Put on Market volume but are hardly yet being discarded.
The new European target, which requires 85% of actually generated waste EEE to be collected in the same year, corrects these shortcomings. Furthermore, the State Secretary for Infrastructure and Water Management has confirmed that, going forward, compliance will be assessed against the 85% target instead of the previous 65% standard. Nonetheless, the fact remains that with a collection rate of 68% under this method, Stichting OPEN also falls well short of the target. The European Commission has therefore issued a notice of default to the Netherlands, and the Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate (ILT) has placed Stichting OPEN under heightened supervision, instructing it to draw up an improvement plan that leads to a higher collection rate.
The PwC report
The PwC report commissioned by Stichting OPEN focuses primarily on the efficiency and benefits of a single-PRO model, as is the case with Stichting OPEN—in other words, a monopoly. According to PwC, such a model would be more effective in tackling 'free-riders', raising awareness, and safeguarding long-term investments. In addition, transitioning to a multiple-PRO system would allegedly bring many problems, such as favouring large corporations and price-based competitive pressure that fails to incentivise better recycling and long-term goals. Interestingly, another study commissioned by European Recycling Platform reaches the opposite conclusion: competition between PROs creates incentives for innovation and efficiency gains, as PROs have a strong motivation to improve the services they offer to their clients. Because the PwC study focuses exclusively on arguments in favour of a monopoly over multiple PROs, the question remains unanswered as to how a PRO system can be designed so that it actually functions efficiently.
Another important point concerns the lack of consultation with relevant stakeholders in the report, such as WEEE Nederland—which now collaborates with Stichting OPEN—and other stakeholders such as knowledge institutions, (municipal) waste collectors, recyclers, and consumer organisations. Without their input, it is difficult to arrive at fully substantiated conclusions, particularly regarding the pursuit of circularity, transparency, and stakeholder participation within PROs.
A position paper by Fair Resource Foundation highlights the risk that PROs could use their position of power for lobbying purposes, while other actors have limited influence. A major reason behind the establishment of the EPR organisation Collectief Circulair Textiel was also to offer an alternative that places circularity and inclusivity front and centre. A white paper on EPR by Utrecht University further emphasises the need for a different governance model for producer organisations, with a clear role for other stakeholders—such as municipalities, waste management companies, and civil society organisations—in setting the PRO's strategy. The white paper therefore advocates for a 'circular value chain management organisation' with broad representation, rather than just producers. The crucial question is therefore not so much whether you can have one or multiple PROs, but what frameworks the government establishes for a PRO. In this context, the EPR further development process currently underway is also very important.
In addition, the study raises further questions about how the results were produced and interpreted, as the analysis is based on comparing the Dutch structure with those of five other European countries. The conclusion that a monopoly would be more effective and efficient is based on this limited comparison. However, the figures in the report do not convincingly demonstrate that countries with a single-PRO system perform better than countries with multiple PROs. That conclusion therefore appears premature. Furthermore, the Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency (PBL) and the CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis
report that the question of under what circumstances monopolistic PROs are more efficient than competing PROs can scarcely be answered empirically, due to excessive disparities between cost factors and waste streams across countries.
Striking similarities
The report displays striking similarities to PwC's conclusions on Verpact, the only Dutch PRO for packaging, which had a virtually identical study conducted by the exact same consultancy firm earlier this year. The premise and conclusions were identical: the current system, in which one entity holds a monopoly, works best. This is unlikely to be a coincidence, as both reports were published in close succession with a similar objective.
All in all, Stichting OPEN will undoubtedly use the findings from the PwC report towards the ministry and other stakeholders in support of their new AVV application, submitted on 1 April 2025. This new AVV is intended to take effect on 1 January 2026. The timing of the publication is also strategic, given the general election on 29 October and the consultation on the European Circular Economy Act, which also focuses on EPR. In this way, the importance of the AVV is highlighted for decision-makers on this topic.
Whether that AVV is granted or not, it is important that we do not reduce the discussion on producer responsibility to an argument over whether or not to have a monopoly, but instead talk about what we expect from EPR. And that is: steering towards circularity instead of merely collection and recycling, greater transparency, genuinely involving stakeholders in EPR, and effective enforcement.




