Evaluation of the reuse measures
Europe aims for a circular economy where reuse is the norm and the throwaway society is curbed. The Single-Use Plastics Directive (SUPD) and the Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR) contain various measures to ban or reduce single-use packaging.

This page is automatically translated. A human review will follow soon.
The Dutch ministerial regulation on single-use plastic products from 2022 (a result of the Single-Use Plastics Directive) aims to reduce the use of disposable cups and containers by 40% in 2026 compared to 2022. The regulation has recently been evaluated, and there is a proposal from State Secretary Chris Jansen (PVV) of the Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management to amend the legislation. This proposal is met with both support and resistance. Among other things, we wonder: could the SUP surcharge not be regulated via the EPR Packaging scheme?
Clear legislation essential for a successful reuse transition
The transition to reuse, in which many millions have been invested by innovative companies striving for a future with less waste and litter, ground to a halt in 2023. An adopted VVD motion led to a temporary freeze on enforcement by the Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate (ILT) regarding the use of plastic-containing disposable packaging prohibited under the legislation. This created market uncertainty, causing investments in reusable alternatives to stall. A successful transition requires clear legislation and enforcement, so that businesses dare to invest and a level playing field is created in which reusable packaging becomes competitive with disposables.
Government proposal to amend current legislation
The evaluation of the ministerial regulation on single-use plastic products in December 2024 resulted in the following proposals for amendment:
Reuse will become mandatory in closed environments, such as offices, restaurants, etc. Only at closed events will the exemption rule allowing the use of disposable packaging under certain conditions still be permitted. (current situation: the exemption for disposable packaging under certain conditions applies to all closed environments)
Reuse measures for delivery services and supermarkets will disappear. (current situation: offering a reusable alternative for delivery is mandatory, and supermarkets must charge a SUP surcharge on certain plastic-containing disposable packaging)
A fixed, mandatory SUP (Single-Use Plastic) surcharge of €0.25 on all plastic-containing disposable packaging for on-the-go consumption (current situation: mandatory SUP surcharge, but the amount may be determined by the final retailer)
SUP policy must push through: no more unnecessary exemptions
Tightening regulations and increasing the SUP surcharge are steps in the right direction. Even though an exemption from the reuse obligation for closed events is not necessary. A closed context is ideally suited for establishing a reuse system. Events, in particular, allow the visitor experience to be designed entirely around this. That is why the European Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR) includes a requirement for on-site consumption from 2030, without exemptions for disposable packaging, including that made from rPET. Delivery can also play a role in the reuse transition, as our southern neighbours are proving with the Boemerang project in Mechelen. For supermarkets, reusable alternatives for certain plastic-containing disposable packaging are indeed limited, but by completely removing the incentive to switch, the (litter) waste generated by the sector will not be reduced. And it is precisely supermarket to-go packaging that is frequently found in litter.
Replacing disposables with disposables does not solve the (litter) waste problem
Material substitution perpetuates disposables
State Secretary Jansen proposes a fixed SUP surcharge – an additional charge – of €0.25 on plastic-containing disposable packaging for to-go consumption, which is not required to be invested in reuse. Consequently, single-use plastic packaging becomes a revenue model: a perverse financial incentive, in other words. The consumer pays, and their money does not contribute to a reusable alternative. Meanwhile, the goal of the measure is to make reuse "the norm". Former State Secretary Heijnen indicated that she trusted business owners would invest the surcharge in reusable alternatives. In practice, this does not happen.
That is why Plastic Soup Surfer Merijn Tinga – with whom we previously raised awareness for disposable coffee cups and reusable alternatives via the Mission Reuse Expedition – and Zwerfinator Dirk Groot are advocating for the abolition of the SUP surcharge. They anticipate that the SUP surcharge will have a minimal effect on reuse and see more effective measures. Among other things, they call for alternative measures to reduce plastic disposable packaging: a ban on plastic disposable packaging for which plastic-free alternatives are already on the market. In doing so, they use their 'discard matrix', which mapped the litter risk of to-go packaging following research in thousands of public bins. Tinga and Groot want the responsibility to lie with the product providers. Various politicians and businesses are now using their call merely to lobby for the abolition of measures surrounding plastic disposable packaging and to encourage disposable alternatives made of other materials such as paper/cardboard. However, this ignores the Dutch government's goal: reusable packaging as the new norm. The litter activists share that goal, which we will not achieve through so-called material substitution: perpetuating the throwaway society where, instead of plastic, we see more and more disposable paper packaging.
The PPWR sets prevention targets: we must generate increasingly less waste per person in the coming years. Reuse is one of the most effective strategies for achieving this reduction. That is why Member States are permitted to go beyond the proposed measures regarding reuse targets and the level of the mandatory EPR percentage for reuse. Product bans on plastic packaging by individual Member States are not allowed, not even within the SUPD from 1 January 2025. They are, however, allowed for other materials, such as paper. Therefore, it is unwise to focus blindly on bans on plastic disposable packaging and a shift to disposable paper packaging; rather, the focus should be on setting up local, national, and international reuse systems.
Make the SUP surcharge effective: levy it via producers
The call by Tinga, Groot, and various political parties from across the spectrum during the last circular economy committee debate, the increasing attention to expanding the EPR (Extended Producer Responsibility) instrument, and the recent call from the Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency (PBL) in their biennial report on the state of the circular economy in the Netherlands (ICER): more and more people and organisations are calling for less burden on the consumer and more responsibility for producers and suppliers. However, this should be achieved without an enormous increase in regulatory burden for businesses. One way to meet these calls is: incorporating a SUP surcharge into the EPR Packaging scheme (and thus collecting it from producers and importers), and mandating that this revenue be invested in reuse, as is already happening in France, Belgium, and Portugal. French producer organisation CITEO is leading the way towards reusable packaging in their country, thanks to steering legislation. By structuring an additional charge for disposable packaging in this way, you secure the necessary investments to achieve scale. Furthermore, this also fulfils the PPWR requirement that producer organisations must begin investing in reuse systems by 2027. Verpact is the Dutch producer organisation for packaging. Market parties have seen the transition to reusable packaging coming for years and are increasingly asking Verpact to take the lead on standardisation, universal systems, and financing. The second Reusable Packaging Fair, with nearly 500 visitors and 60 speakers, demonstrated once again how much is already possible in the field of reuse. Could Verpact play a role here, just like their counterparts in other European countries? Could the €0.25 be contributed to the foundation by producers and importers, just as they are already legally required to contribute to arrangements including the collection of cans and bottles? And could that contribution be mandatorily invested in reuse systems? Naturally, the costs will be passed on to the consumer, but in return they will be offered increasingly more reusable alternatives, which will also become cheaper due to growing economies of scale. This proposal addresses the call from VVD and JA21, who successfully tabled a motion to abolish the SUP surcharge "considering that producers bear a responsibility to reduce plastics in litter".
Tübingen proves: a tax on disposables works
The German municipality of Tübingen decided to tackle waste and litter in their city by levying a local tax on certain disposable packaging. The local McDonald's sued the municipality, but lost after a legal battle that went all the way to the federal supreme court. Many hundreds of German municipalities, and also those in other countries such as Belgium, are preparing to follow Tübingen's example. McDonald's had previously been successful in weakening the European Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR) as the driving force behind unprecedented lobbying efforts for disposable packaging.
Ambiguity regarding single-use vs. reusable packaging
The transition to reusable packaging is essential to meet targets on waste and litter, but can currently also be described as volatile. This is due to both practical challenges in the initial phase and misinformation, which still often causes the retention of disposable packaging to be wrongly seen as the more sustainable option. A number of frequently heard arguments against reuse and their explanations:
Water use: producing and recycling disposable packaging made of plastic (or a mix of paper/cardboard and plastic) requires water, just as producing and washing reusable cups does. Meanwhile, washing facilities for reuse are becoming increasingly efficient as scale increases. In addition, reusable cups are sometimes washed before first use. But why, then, are plastic-containing disposable cups not?
Transport: a disposable cup requires raw materials (plastic, sometimes in combination with paper/cardboard), production and distribution must take place, and processing (recycling or incineration) again requires various transport movements. For reusable packaging, transport movements to the washing facility and to the next user are required after use. Sometimes cups are even washed on-site. In short: transport movements can, at the very least, be considered to cancel each other out.
Production: disposable packaging comes to the Netherlands from all over the world, and the same applies to reusable packaging. The latter are also partly produced in the Netherlands and neighbouring countries. The argument that reusable packaging equates to "plastic from Asia" is therefore an oversimplification.
Few rotations: to be sustainable and cost-effective, reusable packaging must make as many 'rotations' as possible (be reused as often as possible). In the current phase of the transition, we are also seeing lower-quality packaging enter the market, which in practice is only reused a few times. As with any change, these are teething troubles. As the transition progresses, this problem will resolve itself because items will repeatedly have to be repurchased, thus incurring costs. Meanwhile, we are also advocating for a definition of "reusable" that includes, among other things, a minimum number of rotations and the establishment of a system.
Raw materials: disposable cups continuously require new raw materials, either plastic or a combination of plastic and paper/cardboard. Recycling disposable packaging is very difficult: to-go packaging from public bins is largely incinerated. Due to waste exports, they may also end up in landfills elsewhere in the world. And if they are recycled, it is done through downcycling, for example into kitchen rolls or toilet paper. rPET is the only material that can be recycled to food-grade standard, but the market is struggling.
Hygiene: reusable cups and containers are washed and used according to the same hygiene standards as other tableware (think of plates and glasses in the hospitality industry). In the case of BYO (Bring Your Own), it is not the provider of the packaging and contents, but the consumer who is responsible, according to the NVWA (Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority).
Recycling: high-grade recycling of reusable PP cups (a common material for reusable packaging) is technically possible, but not (yet) legally permitted. Downcycling already takes place, for example from cup to tray. As mentioned above: disposable to-go cups are primarily incinerated; in closed environments, recycling is only done to a high grade with rPET, in the best cases.
Cup loss: due to lipstick that cannot be washed off, which represents a negligible percentage.
The transition from disposable to reusable packaging represents a massive shift in our society that will affect everyone. Every change is met with resistance, every transition encounters teething troubles at the beginning, and with every new, sustainable development, businesses emerge that simply want to profit from the new reality without regard for the environment. The practical challenges of initial higher costs, steering consumer behaviour (ease of use), and universal infrastructure can only be resolved by increasing scale.
Why a transition to reusable packaging again?
According to the European Commission, 40% of plastic in Europe is used for packaging. Half of the plastic soup – plastic in seas and oceans – consists of packaging. On average, we generate 186.5 kg of packaging waste per person per year in the European Union. The Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency concluded in its biennial progress report on circular economy goals that, in the Netherlands, we are actually using increasingly more raw materials.




